Numerous factors need to be considered when weighing advantages and disadvantages of the juvenile court system versus the criminal court system.
If the juvenile is accused of a serious crime, it is more advantageous to remain in the juvenile court system where an attempt can be made to rehabilitate the minor versus solely punish him.
I accomplished this in a case where an early plea in a juvenile court murder case, prior to the filing of the anticipated fitness hearing, short-circuited the prosecutions attempt to have the minor tried as an adult and resulted in keeping the minor in the juvenile court.
However, depending upon the level of evidence that the prosecution may have against the minor, it may be more desirous to have a jury of twelve decide his fate rather than the judgment of a single juvenile court judge.
This could be especially applicable when considering the rules of evidence that apply in an adult court compared to a juvenile court. A critical example is that a minor may be convicted in a juvenile court by the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice whereas in adult court a conviction cannot be had upon the testimony of an accomplice unless it has been corroborated by other evidence (In re Mitchell P. 1978 22 C3d 946).
Another strategic advantage to having a minor tried as an adult is in the ease of a less serious offense. Whereas the adult court would punish the offender with a small fine, the juvenile court could take custody, removing the minor from the home.
Another consideration arises when the minor has turned 18 at the time of adjudication. Under Rocker v. Superior Court (1977) 75 CA3d 197, it was held that the minor, who had turned 18, may instigate the fitness proceedings and waive the benefits of juvenile court, thus answering the charges as an adult in a criminal court.
In contrast, the court held In re Anna S. (1979) 99, CA3d 869 that a minor under the age of 18 but over 16 may not demand to be found unfit; therefore, they must be 18 prior to adjudication in order to demand that he be held as an adult.
Continue reading "
Strategic Applications for Trying a Juvenile as an Adult
" »